With a carrot and a stick
WELCOME AGAIN TO THE ARMY!
Every male Singaporean has to do either military or police service or join the civil defense for 2 years soon after becoming 18 years old. The difference in the drawing-in process is profound compared with the so-called compulsory military service in Germany. Equality is not a big word anymore in my home country, where less then one third of all young men have to face any service because of the army downsizing in the past decade. It is simply not fair when some young men ‘accidentally’ are being drawn in to the army and therefore have a disadvantage compared to those who are lucky enough not to face any service, because there are simply not enough positions.
ABOUT SLIM SINGAPOREANS
Well, at least this kind of justice is still present in Singapore, but another regulation marks an interesting difference. Every man is automatically part of the reserve after he leaves and therefore faces the obligation to join the forces for up to 40 total days in a year. My current flatmate, who has done his service with the Singaporean police, had to show up for a shooting exercise just yesterday while he happened to be in S’pore as part of his job with Singapore Airlines.
I was wondering whether this practice meant any danger for the current job, but apparently the Singaporean state fully compensates the respective company with the full salary of the person in question, no matter what enormously paid position he currently has. Understandably, this can be extremely expensive and leads to one simple equation: The better you are paid and the higher your position in your company, the fewer amounts of days you eventually will have to serve a year. This is just a nice, unofficial incentive for the many career-oriented Singaporeans to move up the career ladder even more quickly. Yeahh…
CARROT AND A STICK
Well, even more interesting is the fact that every man has to undergo a physical fitness test every single year up to an age of 40. If you don’t pass the test right away (which involves for example running the 2.4 km in 14 minutes for a 36 year old man) you will have to take part in 6 weeks of training with two 4 hour-sessions a week to MAKE you pass. Nobody really wants to spend 4 hours after a long working day doing exercises and then again 4 hours during the precious weekend for this.
Well, even more interesting is the fact that every man has to undergo a physical fitness test every single year up to an age of 40. If you don’t pass the test right away (which involves for example running the 2.4 km in 14 minutes for a 36 year old man) you will have to take part in 6 weeks of training with two 4 hour-sessions a week to MAKE you pass. Nobody really wants to spend 4 hours after a long working day doing exercises and then again 4 hours during the precious weekend for this.
On the other hand, one can earn from $100 (ca. 50€) to $400 for outstanding performance and is therefore rewarded. For the above example, $400 would mean to run the 2.4km in less then 10.45Min., to do at least 31 sit-ups, 6 chin-ups, do a 4x10m shuttle run in not more than 10.7s and a standing broad jump of more than 215cm. Now, is this one of the main reasons why the number of obese, male Singaporeans is so low? It is striking to see how slim the people here are in general..or is this just another outcome of the ever-prevalent peer pressure and fast lifestyle that penetrates all parts of daily life? I would like to know, how much this system of punishment and reward influences the personal decision of living a healthier life…
Why is something like this not possible in Germany? I mean, not necessarily as part of a follow up to military training, but as a general incentive to live a healthier and therefore at little better life? Government and health insurances could jointly conduct a scheme to pay a certain amount of money for good sportive performance in an optional yearly test (Germans would go nuts if there would be a requirement for this…doesn’t go so well with Bratwursts and beerbellies) This might result in a more motivated society and drive down the costs for the ever-complaining health insurances…huh, am I dreaming here?
And, above all, with some monetary incentive Germany would within no time have the fittest students in the world ;-)
Maik


6 Comments:
Firstly: it is not possible in Germany to have this kind of military service, because we don't live in a country which samples Orwells "1984".
Secondly: German Women serve military service as well. Should they be obliged to do the training until they're 40 years old, too?... for the sake of sexual equality which is fixed in our constitution???
Thirdly: Nevertheless, funny to read, interesting information. Where did you obtain this knowledge? :-)
By
Sandy, at 5:13 PM
hey, Singapore is not a police state...just a 'different trade-off between freedom and security'. Ok, there's a tight leash on media, but you're still free to do what you want..It's really not like living in a police state (let alone like 1984!!) where big brother is watching me all the time (ok, maybe he does. but so far he did not mention it ;-))
Yes..definitely! Why should women be treated in a different way there? The training requirements already differentiate the expected results on the age of men..gender differentiation should be possible, too!
Where I got the information from? Walking around with open eyes and endless questions ;-)
By
Maik, at 5:21 PM
By the way, credit for all the helpful information in this post go to my colleague and friend Khoo Chaik Wah who currently has to endure the mentioned 6 weeks training. Let us all pity him ;-)
And...I got a complaint saying that the depicted Kopi is not Malaysian. However, this was the information I had. I'd be glad if someone could put some light into this..?
By
Maik, at 12:01 AM
Hey.. you know.. you could be the next neil humphreys. You make a good replacement for Neil since he has gone away to Australia.
Mabelline
By
Anonymous, at 1:07 PM
no clue at all who that is...first thing google comes up with is 'Why You Should Die, Neil Humphreys, Albeit Painlessly'..does not make me feel too comfortable ;-)
By
Maik, at 10:26 AM
http://asia.news.yahoo.com/060717/5/singapore219530.html
By
Anonymous, at 9:10 PM
Post a Comment
<< Home